Apple loses patent case enchantment, owes VirnetX $440M in FaceTime dispute

endless loop —

With VirnetX’s patents ruled invalid, Apple has vowed to address case to Supreme Courtroom.

Cyrus Farivar

Group Facetime for as much as 32 simultaneous participants, coming to iOS 12.1.

Group Facetime for as much as 32 simultaneous participants, coming to iOS 12.1.

A federal appeals court has upheld a landmark patent judgment brought by VirnetX in opposition to Apple, putting forward a

$440 million judgment

in a years-prolonged patent dispute.

On Tuesday, the US Courtroom of Appeals for the Federal Circuit denied Apple’s efforts to overturn a 2016 verdict that imposed $302 million in damages. That resolve on has since risen to encompass enhanced damages, curiosity, and more. Many would dub the Nevada-primarily based VirnetX a “patent troll,” because it has no critical provide of earnings exterior of patent litigation.

Previously, a jury chanced on that Apple’s VPN on Rely on and FaceTime facets infringed VirnetX patents. However the Patent Trial and Charm Board has already invalidated VirnetX’s patents, which VirnetX is appealing.

Reuters notorious Tuesday that Apple has vowed to enchantment.

As Ars has previously reported, VirnetX had obtained three separate jury trials in opposition to Apple, all in the Jap District of Texas, a longtime hotspot for patent-keeping firms hunting for to sue tech firms. The first was in 2012, when a jury awarded $368 million in damages and the assume granted an ongoing royalty of one percent. Each and every holdings had been overturned on enchantment, on the other hand.

In February 2016, the jury in a second trial sided with VirnetX in a $625 million verdict in opposition to Apple. However that verdict was thrown out by the trial’s assume, who didn’t approve of VirnetX attorneys’ references to the 2012 trial. A third trial was held in September 2016, and it resulted in a $302 million verdict, which is what the assume added to in his October 2017 judgment.

The case began potential wait on in 2012 with four of VirnetX’s patents (1, 2, 3, 4), all of which originated at a firm called Science Capabilities Global Company, or SAIC.


Leave a Reply