Is the 2019 Coachella Lineup the Weakest of All Time? – Hollywood Reporter


2:26 PM PST 1/3/2019


Jonny Coleman

Is the 2019 Coachella Lineup the Weakest of All Time? - Hollywood Reporter

Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Pictures

Jaden Smith.

It’s faulty, fam.

It’s been accepted for practically a decade to criticize Coachella lineup unearths, ever since the as soon as fringe-y competition elevated itself to this mainstream, hyper-commercialize, AEG-owned behemoth that we all now know. Nonetheless with the day outdated to this’s announcement of the supremely underwhelming 2019 slate, it’s certain that music is now in reality an afterthought and that the organizers don’t like many unique solutions up their sleeves; it’s all about reproduction/pasting extinct lineups.  

Let’s birth with the headliners. After rumors emerged that Kanye and competition producer Goldenvoice couldn’t strike a deal, it now appears to be like that Childish Gambino, Ariana Grande and Tame Impala are the marquee performers. Grande — while an obtrusive pop and radio vast title — feels misplaced. Childish Gambino doesn’t genuinely like the body of work to encourage up being the headliner of any construct of competition, and it’s certain here is ready Donald Glover’s total star and no more about his musical bona fides. Tame Impala is mainly the easiest one who appears to be like to slot in with the standard Coachella ethos and vibe, nonetheless they’ve already played Coachella rather a lot of cases. And Grande and Gambino like as wisely, on this decade.

Right here’s a a ways shout from the days when the competition would book heavies treasure Prince and Daft Punk, or support up memorable reunions treasure Mazzy Megastar, Siouxsie and the Banshees or the Outkast trainwreck from 2014 — or even reunions from counterfeit retirements, treasure LCD Soundsystem about a years encourage. There’ll not be the form of moments promised for this Three hundred and sixty five days’s installment — upright a bunch of serviceable KCRW-form acts alongside about a pop stars and EDM bros.  

For the mid-upper-tier names, there’s practically much less to be vital about. Like, who’s the target audience for Jaden Smith and Russian techno iconoclast and factual weirdo Nina Kraviz? Why are they on a bill precise subsequent to every other? And, certain, artists treasure Solange are proficient, nonetheless she’s looked more than one cases on these same fields. They are going to impartial don’t like any decrease than promoted her to headliner to bump up the stakes slightly.

Essentially the most noise round this lineup tumble appears to be like to be the truth that many people had been unaware that film and TV vast title Idris Elba has been DJing for a long time, which is strange since Elba has been talking about this for years on social media and within the click. The casual fans of music who didn’t know Elba had a musical profession are the core Coachella target audience now, slightly than the more engaged music fans. And the truth that here is the vital myth the click appears to be like to love picked up on yet again reinforces how sleepy this lineup is. Releasing it a day after Novel Three hundred and sixty five days’s Day practically makes it feel treasure they had been attempting to bury the announcement. Like they knew it became as soon as not newsworthy.

A long way too most of the 2019 booked acts like played sooner than — some of them 3 or 4 cases even — and don’t necessarily merit one more appearance, until you treasure spending ungodly portions of money on the an identical ingredient yearly. It’s certain the bookers like decided relationships with decided artists and their administration, and that’s genuinely initiating to prove. The competition routine to be critical better at shuffling the deck and maintaining issues recent — or no decrease than making it feel treasure they had been catering to an target audience that became as soon as voracious and animated. Presumably it’s not doable to program a lineup that feels treasure an occasion or a real cultural moment in 2019; maybe culture is too gigantic and simultaneously too granulated.  

Rap, R&B and radio pop fans per chance like essentially the most to spy ahead to this April, with units from Pusha T and Blood Orange. SoundCloud rap enthusiasts had been thrown a bone via Billie Eilish — whose music is upright simply not very precise — even though she nabbed a second-line build apart a formula or the opposite.

Blackpink represents the first Okay-Pop neighborhood on a Coachella lineup (which feels leisurely), and there’s easiest one steel act, Chon.

Fans of underground dance music and EDM alike like minute to spy ahead to and — as is factual of fans of the total genres represented here — like formula better offerings at distinctiveness and arena of interest festivals, generally at a little bit of the worth, effort or hype. On one hand you’ve obtained Aphex Twin, who continuously brings some surprises, nonetheless for every Aphex Twin, there are eight snoozers treasure Dillon Francis, Bassnectar and Diplo. It doesn’t form any sense. It’s treasure reading an incoherent list of artists from 5 of your guests who like nothing in total.

Coachella rumors routine to be relaxing. Now no one appears to be like to care. You would argue that the relaxing has been sapped from the occasion since they expanded to hosting the occasion over two weekends in a row in 2012 or since Philip Anschutz’s pork up of anti-unfamiliar laws and precise-fly teams has change into evident. Otherwise it is advisable to to per chance well per chance argue that after the abilities trumped the music and so that they began to promote out ahead of publicizing the lineup there became as soon as no turning encourage. That, or the Tupac hologram.

With the ever-swelling rate of attending and exhaustion of solutions and imaginative and prescient within the booking division, it’s certain that the Empire Polo Fields will not be a situation designed for relaxing music discovery. It’s now upright a situation the build apart brands form activations and prosperous children jog to occasion. Pour one out.  

  • Jonny Coleman


Leave a Reply